Who receives the putout for R2 after a proper appeal in Situation I?

In the context of this scenario, the putout for R2 after a proper appeal is correctly attributed to the nearest designated baseman, often referred to as F4, who plays shortstop. When a player on base is called out as a result of an appeal, the responsibility for recording that putout typically falls on the player who was closest to the action when the appeal was made. Since F4 is positioned to cover the area near the base where the appeal was established, they are in the best position to handle the play and take the putout. This rule emphasizes the relevance of field positioning and the roles of the defensive players during the game.

Other players such as the catcher, pitcher, or shortstop could be involved in different plays, but in this specific case, the role of F4 as the nearest designated baseman makes it clear why that player receives the putout. This reinforces underlining concepts of proper base coverage and situational awareness in baseball.